In case you ever wondered, my Tivo can kick Replay’s butt. Replay doesn’t let you set a priority to your recordings and you can’t use it at all if you don’t have the service – meanwhile I used my Tivo like a VCR for a week when I moved, manually setting up channels & times to record. Tivo ROCKS. Don’t question it. They don’t even mention the fact that Tivo has a larger market share – you hear people say “I Tivo’d Friends last night”. You never hear people say “I Replay’d that show.” Go Tivo! Go Tivo!