Stamped Logo Choices…

I’m at a crossroads in a decision, and the indecisive part of me can’t decide. I recently worked with Sara of Sadie Olive on redesigning the blog header for Christine Tremoulet. I love it. I’m thrilled with it. It coordinates with my studio, and makes it all feel so tied together. Thing is, we did a “stamped” effect on the logo (which I adore), and I’m trying to figure out if I should carry that effect over to my actual sign that I’m having made for the studio.

Stamped

It is either that or go with my logo “as is” instead:
The Logo

The logo colors would stay the same — I’m just trying to decide if I want it to have that slight texture effect.

Feedback? Thoughts? Ideas? Heeeeeeeeeeeeeeeelp…

Edited: I changed out the photo here because I realized it was confusing people. The sign that I plan to have made will be a light cream color, and will have the logo in blue/black on it. Just like the official logo above. I’m just trying to decide if I want the really crisp lines, or for it to have a more “textured” effect like the black logo on burlap above it.

The sign won’t be black lettering, it will be blue & black. It is the effect, how it looks like it is stamped, that I was asking about.